New council will face mystery of charges for new farm buildings
Administrator | Nov 17, 2026 | Comments 0

Sue Capon file photo
By Sharon Harrison
The idea of charging local farmers a development charge for putting up a new farm building brought lengthy, argumentative, but important discussion at council’s last meeting for this term of council.
The discussion began with a proposed resolution from councillors Bill Roberts and Sam Branderhorst who sought council’s support that eligible agricultural buildings be exempt from development charges (DCs).
It became unclear how or why DCs were being applied to farm buildings because they had been exempted under the DC bylaws, where the issue only recently came to light when local farmers received a bill. Moreover, staff and council seemed to have no idea exactly when, how or why the change to the DC bylaw came into force, or even that local farmers were subject to the fee, coming to light only when those affected farmers raised the issue.
“We need to do everything we can to reverse this situation,” said councillor John Hirsch, as he addressed Arryn McNichol, director of finance and IT.
“You said that the DCs act requires us to do this, but was that a change that happened in 2023 because my understanding is we had no DCs on such farm buildings up until a small change was made which, mea culpa, we all missed around the horseshoe when we approved the fees and charges for 2023,” stated Hirch.
“Was there a legal change at that time, or was it an oops that should have been done? I mean even the agricultural advisory committee wasn’t consulted, it just kind of happened by magic, so I’m just trying to understand how that happened.”
McNichol said, he was not too sure how that happened as he was not involved in the DC background study.
“I know that in 2018 it was not included and that was a policy choice of council, and in 2023, I could only assume that would be a policy choice by council. I can’t really comment on it other than it is in our background study and included in our bylaws and affects five service areas, so I’m not too sure how that happened.”
After one motion failed, council approved a second motion that directs staff to suspend the collection and payment of development charges for qualifying registered farm businesses, pending council’s decision on the proposed agricultural building exemption.
Staff will bring back a report in the first quarter of 2027 with recommendations to implement an exemption for eligible agricultural buildings, including the implications, options and potential approaches for such an exemption, and consideration of any development charges previously paid by eligible agricultural operations.
This was especially relevant as it relates to refunding those DCs that have already been paid, of which there appears to be at least one, where McNichol confirmed a DC bylaw amendment would be required in order to reverse funds already paid.
The DC exemption would apply uniquely to actual farmers registered as farm businesses, and to non-residential buildings used primarily in support of farm business ventures.
While a few councillors wanted to have the entire matter wrapped-up there and then and reversed, others, including staff and the municipal clerk, highlighted the significance of council being in a lame duck position where any expenditure or liability must not exceed $50,000, along with emphasising the complexity of the issue which cannot be rushed.
“Staff have not done the analysis, we don’t know how the suspension, how the monetary value of this suspension, what it means,” said clerk Catalina Blumenberg. “We don’t know how many farmers are impacted, we know of one farmer who shared what their bill was, another farmer shared another person’s bill that is not present. Those two bills that we know of right here and right now are over $50,000.”
Two members of the farming community spoke in support of exempting the DCs for farm buildings, including Don William who has recently assumed the role of president with the Prince Edward Federation of Agriculture (PEFA). He said they were not consulted at all about the changes, suggesting the matter hasn’t been handled very professionally.
“Most council members did not know that it was in place and something this important, on the size of these projects, there are four or five of us that are looking to put up big barns this summer and several of them are on the go already and they’ve gotten the bill for this development charge,” expressed William. “I would love for it to be reversed tonight, but I know that you won’t be able to do that. It’s one huge amount of money… they are biting at our butts.”
Third generation Prince Edward County dairy farmer David Prinzen spoke to how after 26 years of getting through some hard and bad years (some good ones too), he got on his feet this year and was able to build a new barn.
“We got hammered with a building fee, $33,000 – for a barn. What service does the County need to provide to service my barn? There is no water, no sewer… we don’t get any benefit at all from these fees,” shared a frustrated Prinzen.
“As farmers, it’s like… I understand development fees because it’s not fair to charge the local population for growth, but that’s exactly we you’re doing, you’re charging the local population for development that I won’t use, that my cows will never use, we’re not going to the library, we’re not going to go to school, the cows won’t.”
He said, to put into perspective how much it cost him, the fee he got for the barn ($33,000) and a manure pit ($1,800) “cost more than what I made last year. These amounts of money that you are charging are just crippling is what they are. Its just ridiculous amounts of money for nothing”.
He said, only one person has paid the development fee ($27,000) which he said is well under the $50,000 limit of council. “I would like to go ahead with my barn, but I cannot pay the development fee.”
Branderhorst asked Prinzen what this message sends to individuals who might want to take over their family farms, build, grow and try and build a future here, with Prinzen replying how it makes it more unaffordable.
“All this does is, it drives up the price of food, it’ll just stifle innovation and just increase the cost of food. It makes you not want to get into it; it just becomes too hard is what it is.”
McNichol said the issue is a very complex one as he explained how there are five service areas involved, along with a legal requirement to actually collect the DC, and is why they need more time.
“I was doing some research on whether we have the ability to actually refund and not collect, I looked at the DC rebate program which allows for retroactive payment for DCs through a bylaw amendment. It is an incredibly complex issue and we are going to reach out to legal and Watson as we prepare this report.”
He said in order to do a bylaw amendment, staff would have to bring back a report to council with some amendments to the bylaw to give them the authority to actually make those repayments.
Both David Harrison and Roberts asked, given how some farmers have gone ahead or are planning on going ahead with their buildings but haven’t paid their DC, could they go ahead and have the building department issue a permit without paying the DC.
The short answer is “yes” confirmed Cristal Laanstra, director of development services, stating building permits could be issued.
“We are hoping this will allow us to issue those building permits while we are figuring out in the interim how any amendments to our bylaws will impact the municipality,” she said. “At this point, we feel that this is giving direction to calculate what these DCs fees would be under the current approved bylaws. We would have those invoices, we would just not be acting on collecting them at this point.”
However, providing refunds to those DCs already paid is another issue, with Laanstra explaining how a certain amount needs to be covered and then apportioned among all of the service levels.
“If we are taking away a specific class that we have said is being charged that needs to be re-distributed amongst the other classes which is difficult for us to do this evening. That is the portion that is tricky and we are just not sure how to do that,” she said.
The five services affected are ambulance, road, fire, park and recreation and library (long-term care is not affected nor is waste diversion, McNichol confirmed), where he said the shortfall would have to be made up from non-DC sources.
He further confirmed the DC monies paid would be for growth-related capital identified in the background studies, identifying the five service areas. He also explained that the amount paid out already, apportioned to each of the services, if they are refunded, that amount would have to be made whole, and that would have to be done through taxation, grants or any non-DC source.
Blumenberg reminded that there are seven bylaws that were approved, adding how this is very complex legislation to do on the fly, with a lot of room for error.
“We are still going to be trying to achieve a reduction and re-evaluation with new council, perhaps implementing the exemption,” Blumenberg explained. “And then we can do that with an actual report and analysis, and not on the fly without bylaws prepared to rescind the seven bylaws that are in effect right now as that has consequences for the other services.”
Councillor Chris Braney who sits as a director on the PEFA said their last meeting was “quite sombre”.
“Farming in Prince Edward County has been steeped in rich tradition for over 200 years and it’s built our community. Food security is paramount and we need to support our farmers… we need to support these families, we need to have their children that want to continue on with farming, so we can sustain our food security and also a way of life we have all embraced and loved.”
“Clerical errors and things do happen, but I think we owe it to do the right thing as soon as we can,” Braney added.
Councillor Roy Pennell said it was his understanding that Prince Edward County is the only municipality in Ontario charging DCs on farm buildings, to which Braney said he was correct.
“From the research I’ve done, my colleagues from the PEFA did mention that the Ontario Federation of Agriculture provincial statement is for municipalities not to charge development fees for agriculture buildings on farms,” confirmed Braney.
“We are the only municipality that’s done this which you can understand the concern of the farmers of Prince Edward County who have led the way in farming in Ontario for generations, and it was a concern.“
Further information along with the resolution as discussed at the Nov, 10 council meeting can be found on the corresponding agenda item on the County’s website, along the with meeting recording.
Filed Under: Featured Articles
About the Author:














