Open Letter to the Premier
Steve Campbell | Jul 29, 2015 | Comments 63
Ms. Wynne, I’m sure it will come as a surprise to you that Prince Edward County residents are angry and frustrated to the point of explosion. I assume this is surprising information, considering you have evoked our democratic right to voice our opinion concerning proper location of Industrial Wind Turbines, and thus take control of our own future.
As a column writer and a vocal proponent of our County lifestyle, I would like to state my purpose upfront: The people of the County insist on the cancellation of two wind projects poised to destroy our south shore.
Couldn’t be simpler, and sources tell me that you and the Ministries of Energy and Environment have that ability in your hands.
Our concerns are explosive on a number of fronts: the removal of our rights, the override of our elected municipal council’s decision to be “not a willing host”, the cost effectiveness and necessity for IWTs (our local solar manufacturing company claims to already be supplying four times the electrical power we consume here in the County through solar farms alone) and, of course, the destruction of turtles, bats, birds (in a designated Important Bird Area) and other wildlife, and the removal of their feeding, breeding and resting sources in an extremely fragile ecosystem.
In short: You don’t save the world by destroying wildlife and corrupting the land.
It’s tragic that local naturalists and environmentalists – as eager as you are to fight carbon emissions – have been forced to wage a battle with Ministry of Environment – which pretends to be a protector of all of the above concerns we have expressed. The hypocrisy of your government is appalling!
You pretend to pay attention to our arguments, but only by your rules, through legal means, and with an extremely limited field of allowable objections.
And, of course, your so-called studies on health effects and wildlife devastation – bought and paid for – narrow the field even further, making claims for a utopic future which are not substantiated by evidence.
I suspect your ministries know little about power generation, conservation and preservation, and lots about how to sign expensive deals with corporations.
I also know that you want to fulfill Dalton McGuinty’s Green Dream, and leave a legacy as a world leader. Here you will be remembered as a draconian fascist/communist (we haven’t decided on that yet) bureaucracy who holds their ill-conceived edicts above the wants, needs, sensitivities and sensibilities of Prince Edward County.
I see possible action of Caledonia proportions, with coverage by local, metro and national press – which will make both of us look like crazed fools in the eyes of the country.
Though “unwilling host” is a rather benign term, I’m afraid you might find out how completely unwilling we can be.
I strongly suggest you abandon your plans for destruction of our south shore at Ostrander Point and through the recently-approved White Pines Development.
This is our land, and our lifestyle, and the feeling here is that nothing will make us give it up for the legacy dream of someone else, miles away, who only understands urban concerns and considers rural Ontario to be a vast exploitable wasteland.
You are not good stewards of our land – we are.
In effect, you have made us all powerless against your bulldozers, and this is not something that sits well in a community with strong Loyalist roots.
Cancelling these projects would transform our perception of you from ‘despotic ruler’ to ‘visionary leader’.
Sadly, I fear my words will mean nothing to you, and you will simply put on your blindfold, put your fingers in your ears, and wait for the Big Bang.
But single-minded pursuit of destruction of land, life and communities does not a good government make.
Please give this – and us – some consideration.
Filed Under: News from Everywhere Else • Steve Campbell
About the Author:
What a crock! Does anyone believe that the vast majority of County residents support Turbines. Supporting that is why would they? What is the benefit unless you are one of 27 landowners selling out.
lets not ignore the unknown demographics and the provocative leading of the statements
Old Man, the polls are easily explained. The Quinte News poll had over 1000 votes. 80% in favour of White Pines. Although somebody claimed to have voted multiple times, repetitive votes are not counted, unless you are using different computers. Try it. The results don’t change.
The Green Quinte poll does not report the number of votes, only the resulting percentages. When you wrote your comments, it was 33% yes and 67% no. I voted once. That changed the results to 40% yes and 60% no. Therefore we can determine that there had been 3 votes for yes and 6 votes for no. My vote changed it to 4 votes yes and 6 votes no. Therefore there are currently 10 votes cast. That is less than 1% of the participation in the Quinte News poll.
Not too difficult to see which poll is more reliable in its representation.
the Quinte News poll of July 17/15 being often cited in the comments used the following statements
No. Residents don’t want turbines, and they will have a negative impact on the natural environment and the local economy.
Yes. No one likes change, but we have to stop killing people by creating energy from sources that pollute the environment.
80% support was for the second yes statement
http://www.quintenews.com/2015/07/more-push-back-on-wind-farm-approval/91816/
however
A July 15/15 green quinte poll had the discrepant results using the same statements
with 67 support for the first no statement
http://greenquinte.com/polls/
Why the discrepancy between the exact same poll statements. It seems the wording of the statements are weighted to compel a response.1080 responses were made to the Quinte News poll but there is no information as to the demographics. The preponderance of them could be made by those in the Quinte area who do not reside in PEC and have no worry over IWT’s. One person commented:’The problem with the survey was it allowed one person multiple votes. I, personally, voted 4 times.” from:
http://www.quintenews.com/2015/07/white-pines-on-council-agenda/92453/
FUSION VS THE UNICORN
Compact Fusion · Lockheed Martin
http://www.lockheedmartin.ca/us/products/compact-fusion.html
Cheap fusion beats fossil fuels – EE Times Europe
http://www.electronics-eetimes.com/…/cheap-fusion-beats-fossil-fuels.html?...
“The wind power industry claims switching from conventional power to wind power will save consumers money and spur the economy. However, data from the top 10 wind power states show just the opposite.”
http://www.forbes.com/sites/jamestaylor/2014/10/17/electricity-prices-soaring-in-top-10-wind-power-states/
Nuclear fusion???? really? Did you honestly suggest a nuclear reaction that only occurs in the centre of stars would fit in the back of a pick up truck? Unless this was facietious it defeats your whole argument. While you’re at it lets see how much energy we can get from ground unicorn horn and leprechaun gold?
At Sharon, in case you forgot, in 2012, 489 people in South Marysburgh voted AGAINST wind turbines to 51 people for.
That’s 90% against locally. I would only assume that if 10 or families stood to benefit off of the wind turbines, that it wouldn’t be unreasonable that there could be 3 to 5 family members or close friends that support. What this means Sharon, is that basically 9 out of 10 people in SM do NOT support your GREED. Do I have hate in my heart for what you have done? Absolutely. Enjoy your riches.
I recently sold farmland at East Lake. In speaking with realtors this week in regards to the Milford area it is always the same response. Too late!
There is a lot of cheap land available in South Marysburgh. I would expect that the wise would have disposed of property several years ago. If not, enjoy the massive invasion. The beautiful landscape will never be the same again!
Question for Sharon (and I mean this kindly) – what happens if the turbines go up, begin operating, and the landowners find that there are indeed health issues associated with them and they are no longer able to live in their home? Are there escape clauses in the contracts? Are there gag orders? Can these companies put roadways and power lines wherever they wish on the leaseholders land, or are the locations of these guaranteed in the lease? Are there guarantees that the turbines will be removed when they are no longer operational, or is the land owner going to end up being responsible for the costs of dismantling them?
I just find these leases extremely risky, regardless of the financial gain. We are handing over our land to foreign owners – I doubt they are overly concerned about land stewardship in rural Ontario.
Who is “you” you are referring to? The vast majority? $$ make people do strange things.
First off I think Wynne is awful and needs be pulled out of office. 2nd of do not presume to think you speak for all residents of my beloved home of Prince Edward County. Some county folk are on board with this and have looked into the situation and this is a way of survival and keeping our family lands in the family as they have been for generations. If you are going to speak for a group of people make sure you are actually speaking for everyone.
Come on Judy, the next thing you will try to tell us is that Turbines are Green with no huge carbon footprint.
Judy; visit windvictimsontario.com and have a good read. lol
@ Sam, Judy and Daniel….
Sticking your heads in the sand won’t help. And Daniel that was over 90% against not 80% for. If you are going to use numbers, then please, don’t just make them up.
An Example of local ingenuity and co-operation at a private/public sector in creating less obtrusive green energy
“Peterborough Utilities is partnering with Veridian and the City of Belleville on a power generation venture that involves implementing hydraulic power generation at three Belleville dams, placing Belleville among the first to use such technology.
Mark Turney, Veridian’s vice-president of operations, said the objective is to apply to the FITT 4 program next month.
“It would be one of the first in North America,” Turney said of the dams. “They have a low impact on the environment and they’re particular to any of the type of fish that are in the Moira River.
“Each project is about $4 million and produces about 1,900 megawatts each per year. The FITT rate is forecasted to be around $240 per megawatt hour.”
Veridian Connections, Quinte Conservation, Peterborough Utilities and Belleville now make up the consortium of partners bidding to have the projects plugged into the Ontario Power Authority’s renewable energy feed-in-tariff contract. The feed-in-tariff contract would be for 40 years. All three sites are owned by Quinte Conservation, set to make $12,000 per year for each rental. Capacity of each project would range from 375 to 500 kilowatts, with one grid connection bridged through Veridian and two through Hydro One distribution.”
from the Peterborough Examiner June 23/15
In 2009 Belleville retrofitted the conservation authority’s McLeod dam built in 1979 to generate hydro. Such projects reinforce the concern of the auditor general that the province with the GEA did not fully evaluate the “impact, the trade-offs, and the alternatives.”
The graphs on this web site are or anybody who think that because two things happened at the same time they must be related. Like wind turbines and eggs without yolks.
http://www.tylervigen.com/spurious-correlations
For the rest of us who know better, they are still good for a laugh.
Seriously, Daniel is right. And I don’t believe a word of the so called Australia story.
For one thing, eggs without yolks would signify a nutritional problem. But it’s all unbelievable anyway.
Tell the people in Waterloo, Australia that Daniel. Severe life threatening health conditions. Eggs with no yolks, cattle miscarriages at high levels. Properties boarded up and left behind. Would you like to live next door to one?
they have also proven that there is no health risks with wind turbines. Can you say the same for the other options? there is no valid argument to not put them here.
county residents are about to explode? doubtful, over 80% of residents are for the turbines. this argument is stupid. lets keep raping the land for oil while killing the environment just so, currently, you don’t have to look at turbines in your backyard. out of the options, nuclear, coal, oil or wind and solar, which is better? and i dont mean for your pocket or land value, i mean for future generations. get over your selves and fight to change the real problems facing the born and raised county residents.
Yes Sam, we should just be suppressed and do as we are told!
So many amazing and unique ideas. Letter writing, threats of civil disobedience and road blockades, even poetry. It is too bad that the other “victims” of wind turbines weren’t as clever in their efforts to oppose.
Steve,
There is a list of MPPs with contacts here:
http://www.ontla.on.ca/web/members/member_addresses.do?locale=en
I agree with Mark, probably Todd Smith would have an easier way of doing it.
You have it all wrong. Don’t go for the destruction or health. Go for they are dumping hydro now as the grid can’t handle what HYDRO is producing. So they put us on well don’t us it here but use it here and then they through it away because they can’t handle. Why don’t they fix the grid so it can handle what it produces now before adding more waste to it. 🙂
Factual info
Well Steve I’ve been saving these lyrics for the right time. I was inspired by Bruce Cockburn”s protest song “Call it Democracy” and felt I needed to take the spirit of the song and apply it to what is happening today with our government(s). I was thinking Cockburn’s melody could be applied but I would be happy for others to come up with their own melody and feel free to add/modify the lyrics
And They Call it Democracy
our rights are to deny, our concerns are to ignore,
divide and conquer, favour some, alienate more
pick your candidates who may not be the best
but can you sell their name and image unlike the rest
use the media when you can bend the truth
make us feel hopeless in the voting booth
bribe, intimidate, manipulate the vote
more regulations, more restrictions you have us by the throat
we care for your community and its environment is what you say
but harm the land and wildlife when things don’t go your way
hide behind false ideals and use them for deceit
bloat the bureaucracy, reward buddies we call the elite
legislate with impunity and close off debate
consider the opposition is only there to berate
and when things get hot shut the place down
those looking for truth make them look like a clown
mismanage, overspend, borrow like theres no tomorrow
cut our services, increase our costs add to our sorrow
use your fake majority to go your own way
but when the election time comes we will make you pay
Steve; contact our MPP’s Todd Smith’s office. They will have the distribution list for all MPP’s and I am confident would assist.
Everyone is free to use this in any way they wish.
I have sent to the Premier & 2 ministers, and all the metro papers as a possible op/ed piece: Globe, Star and National Post, and have a reach out for a friendly source at the Sun (since it will only allow 150 words).
I have invited each of them to contact me for information, and will connect them with the proper County groups, if they take up an interest in the story.
The MPP idea is a GREAT one! Don’t know how to do it without tracking them down one by one. Any ideas?
Your responses have done a great deal to lift my despair … great to know there are ‘count on’ people out there.
I truly believe we need to all join forces and mobilize. And there is a time and a place for civil disobedience. This is one.
I believe PAUL BLISS of CTV who is the Queen’s Park Bureau chief would make good use of this information. Maybe Pat Forran, the CTV consumer advocate as well…. Can anyone tell me if I may forward Steve’s letter? thanks
Steve, may be a bit of work, but it would be great to see a copy of this sent to all of the Ontario MPPs. Liberal MPPs are probably the only people that actually have some power to stop this woman.
This letter captures the sentiment of the people of rural Ontario more than any other that I’ve come across.
I suggest forwarding this letter to the Globe, the Financial Post and the National Post. There are people “from away” who would be mortified by all this. May I forward the letter, with your name, on your behalf to the editors or can someone give me permission to do so. I will be one of those civil activists you mention, by the way…
Steve, this is the best articulation of rural Ontarians’ feelings about WTs that I’ve read so far. Reading it, this Amherst Islander cheered aloud.
The time of writing till our fingers wear out and fighting in court till the money runs out are drawing to an end. As you note, the former gets us nothing but form letter replies and the latter, endless debates about what the meaning of “is” is. And always at our expense.
If / when a call goes out to mobilize, there are plenty of p.o’d rural folks across the province who are ready and able to answer.
Well written Steve. Nailed it!
The only thing that would make this perfect … having our ELECTED mayor hand deliver this to the Premier on everyone’s behalf.
Excellent Letter… Some how this present provincial government and past(liberal of course) reminds me of a past( 1939 ) well known government in Europe . And we all know what happened there….
The WPD approval has gotten my hackles up like never before. that’s my backyard…and though it may seem like a straightforward ‘not in my backyard’ argument, it is SO much more than that. Industrial development should require FAR MORE forethought than these turbines have been granted — why not in an already industrial area like a main Hydro corridor or along the 400 series highways that crisscross Ontario? Along the shores of Lake Ontario in Prince Edward County, where we see all kinds of wildlife enjoying our protected fields and forests and shores, it just seems so short-sighted.
Thanks for this letter. I hope it (and our collective ‘disobedience’ to follow) makes a difference!
Best letter ever Steve…boggles the mind that they/she and all of them consistently ignore the people they feign to represent….how is it that they can make such heartfelt promises going into their jobs then proceed to ignore, backtrack, deny, and outright misrepresent once they get into those cushy positions…its shameful! Are there no honest people in high places when we need them???
I just messaged the editor of the Toronto Star requesting publication of both letters. Anyone can do this and the more the better.
Steve – so very happy to hear that you have sent copies beyond the County! We’ll keep our fingers crossed 🙂
You nailed this one!
Wonderful letter Steve…. as always!
We WILL win this fight! I am excited to participate in whatever it takes and pray that many, many others join in.
Keep up the dialogue please to ensure everyone stays motivated. SO important!
County friends and neighbours – let’s really stand strong together on this.
Thanks so much for sharing my rage and our frustration with ‘government gone wrong’.
This has been sent to the Premier and the two Ministries, and I am forwarding a condensed version (150 words) to all the metro Toronto newspapers as a Letter, with the full version as well, in case they might choose it as an op-ed piece.
We really need to educate the city people about the consequences of ‘destruction of the earth, to save the earth’.
I think it was Darwin who said: “If all the insects on earth died tomorrow, there would be no life left on the planet in 10 years. If all the humans died, the earth would prosper.”
Much of what you have written is absolutely true and, as you suggest, many of the residents here in South Marysburgh are in the mood for a fight.
I received an email this afternoon advising that the PECFN v. Ontario (MOECC) ERT commences on September 2 at 10:00 a.m. at Demorestville Town Hall and is scheduled to continue to September 4th. It goes without saying how important it is that this be well attended.
Perhaps the best letter thus far on the iniquities of the socalled Green Energy Act & its related outmoded and environmentally harmful technologies. There is nothing GREEN or democratic about the Liberal’s socalled Green Energy program. Indeed, it is certainly anything but that for rural and small town Ontario whose political & economic rights are being abused in this process.
Steve: thanks for expressing what we’re all thinking.
One look at Wolfe Island will scare anyone that still thinks turbines fit here and are a good idea. Hopefully Wynne will be stopped in the next election. If that’s not too late.
This letter is worth framing. I will definitely save copies as information handouts for the “coverage by local, metro and national press” coming to the County when the creative protests you warn her of irrupt.
The real culprit in all this is Dalton McGuinty…….he and his liberal cronies have bled this province dry…..no wonder he packed his bags and headed back to the Ottawa valley…..Wynne is just one of his pupils…..she knows no other way of governing.
Send this to the Toronto newspapers.
Great letter Steve!
How do we get letters such as these published beyond the local area?
Steve Campbell, this is, in my opinion, a terrific letter and puts into words everything that I have been thinking and feeling.
Nobody likes to be bulldozed and that’s what I feel is happening, we are being bulldozed by our own government into accepting something that I for one deem to be unnecessary.
We definitely need to find alternate and more environmentally friendly sources of energy in order to aid in the preservation of our world, however, the destruction of the rural landscape is absolutely not the way to go and would be counter-productive.
Thank you for your letter